Hi Kawabob1,
Your AYP made mower aka Craftsman 917,xxx,xxxx has, if I remember correctly, 1/2" x 93 1/2" deck belt. You've stated in your #1 OP post that you're using something non-OME that is 5/8" by XXX" in size. Check that and make sure that it is, without any doubt a 5/8" in size. Personally, I'd doubt that because if your deck belt starts with 1/2" so is/must be the snow blower belt. Second thing I'd like you to verify is that you're not just using any non-OEM belt for your replacement. Keep in mind that an ordinary V-belts, such as the ones used for wall exhaust fans, cement mixers, etc., don't bend backwards as the lawn mower belts do. Despite the fact that there are of the same size are not interchangeable! Lastly, try to find the 917.xxx xxx model number on your mower and maybe we can match it with the exact snow blow you have, and, consequently, get you the exact belt info you're ISO?