I'm bought in with this idea, but what no one ever talks about is what attributes of either the blades or deck actually have an impact on cut quality. As an engineer, I'd love for someone to be able to point to something specific on the deck of my mower that is causing the issues I see.
I had a similar question about blade design that I posted on this forum or another some time back. I see so many posts where people suggest, "try high lift blades", or "try gator blades", but so little discussion of the science behind why one blade might be better than another for its intended purpose.
Not arguing with your point at all, just wishing we as an internet community could get more science behind the discussion to help understand the issues we're seeing, or at least help others make good choices.
I'm just a self educated enjiner but I can tell you about the best mower I ever had for discharging / clean cut and a weed whacker edger was never needed to trim.
It was about 40 years ago when I was poor as a snake and raising 3 kids. I needed a mower, pusher of all things. I had an old engine from somewhere, probably the old Homeko mower that had a failed two speed, a blade from a mower shop. An old ugly yellow deck that looked like a doughnut, ( think Snapper RER with a depression for the engine ) 4 adjustable wheels and a handle from a co worker that kept a few old mowers around. So looking back this pusher was built up from at least 5 mowers.
Now, here is what made it work. The eng. shaft was too long so I cut a 3/4" thick plywood ring to elevate a little but the blade tip still was down at the bottom deck edge or just a little below and to top that off the blade only missed the deck about an 1/8". One did not place his boot toe anywhere close to the deck with it running. Just avoid that area even with steel toed boots.
Why wasn't a trimmer edger needed? It would suck 6" long grass from around a tree, off of a brick wall or from chain link fence. It even wanted some of that tall grass on the opposite side of the fence.:laughing:
It's last breath was the day we expanded the mowing area here at the ranch and went for a rider. The day I took it to the scrapper it still had the wooden LF wheel I had made from a 2x10 after the plastic wheel hub fell completely out taking a corner too fast.
That's my story and I'm sticken to it.