Hi David,
I just looked at the spindle pulleys on my 2008 Tiger Cub and they don't have any rust on them, oxidation yes. Are you in a high humidity area? Does your dealer leave machines outside? Does your dealer water wash their in stock machines? The machine bolts in the pulleys are cad plated class 8 bolts which don't corrode quickly, the other rusty area is exposed metal. Do all three spindle pulleys have the rust on the same areas? Your pic is of the center spindle pulley.
Was this a demo machine?
I suggest that you raise up the front of the machine, which you need to do to perform a blade change, remove the blade bolt nuts, I do this with an air impact wrench and 15/16" socket, pull the blades and bolts out and inspect them for corrosion. The blade bolts are 9 1/2" long and the machine needs to be raised up to allow the bolts to clear the bottom of the spindles. To correctly install the blades and bolts, the nut torque is 75 FTLBs. I use a long breaker bar with socket to hold the bolt head under the deck, and torque the nuts from the top with a torque wrench. With that much corrosion/rust on the pulley tops, I would be concerned about the condition of the bolts and nuts as when they get corrosion in the nut/bolt threads, they can be a bear to remove. I had to drill small holes radially in one nut and then split it with a hammer and chisel to remove it and I do 3-4 blade changes in season.
Mad Mackie in CT:laughing::biggrin::smile: