For the money you are talking you can buy a brand new John Deere Z-465 with 62 inch deck.We are purchasing a home with 6 acres to mow in Indiana. It is flat with a decent number of trees. I'm thinking a zero-turn is my best bet with a 60" deck, and was initially overwhelmed by my options. I am wanting the best mower for the money that will last a long time (doesn't everyone?). While I love the durability of a commercial mower, I just don't think I need to spend that much. I've kind of narrowed it down to the John Deere X465 and the Dixon Ultra 61. Both seem to be top of the line residential mowers for around $5,500. If I go with commercial quality, it seems I'll be spending at least $3,000 more. Any suggestions between the two? Am I missing something else out there that would be quality for the same or less money? Thanks for the help!
Between the two you mention it would be a easy decision for me.Went to look at the Dixon Ultra 61 today, and was very impressed. I really feel like it is going to be hard decision between the JD Z465 and the Dixon. The engine in the Dixon is a 27 hp Kohler Courage vs. the 27 hp Briggs with cyclonic air filtration in the JD. Anyone have experience or feelings on the two engines or any other aspect of the mowers? Dixon's are not talked about very much on this forum, so I gather they aren't nearly as popular (at least with the regular contributors.)
I really like my new EZ Trak but I just got it this spring so it has little use yet.Thanks Bart. I see you own a Z445 which appears to the same as the Z465 just with a slightly smaller deck, so I am guessing by your recommendation that you are fully satisfied with the mower.
I also see you own a Grasshopper which I consider to be a commercial mower (at least they are priced that way.) I would also be interested in you comparing the two. Again, I'm looking at 6 acres and my budget makes new commercial quality mowers out of the question, but the dealers (and my more affluent farmer friends) all say that commercial built mowers. I just don't think I need that much quality when I'll only have it running a few hours a week. Would you agree?
Sorry to ask so many questions but I haven't actually spoken with anyone who owns a Z445 or 465.
Although a zero turn is going to the most efficient way to cut grass, a compact tractor is much much more versitile. I know you've spent a lot of time laboring over this decision and I don't want to confuse you but 6 acres is a large parcel and if you have any serious landscaping aspirations, consider the compact tractor if you have not already.With the amount of property you have a good used compact or very large GT would be, by far, your best bet-you will find lots of other things to do with it that a ZT could never, ever do; in the long run a nice diesel tractor will last longer than you do and pay for itself a few times over. A sixty one inch deck is huge, your property is gigantic-I don't see anything but a cut, gt making it more than a few years.
Then again if I were so smart I wouldn't still be stuck with a poop zt that has been in the shop more than it has been in our yard.
I personally had to make a similar choice and I went with a compact tractor. This is my second one, I sold the first (i don't collect mowers). I just got off my machine, and I stood back and admired it for a few seconds before I came in for water (it's 107F here now).hmm , great thread , i may re-consider now also......3-6 acres and you may hav some brush/pasture type mowing , ZTR could break..........compact tractor with PTO may be the better option.......is this correct .???
Years ago I tried to plow snow with a GT I put on tire chains and it was better but still would not push snow so I added wheel weights better but not enough so I added 400 lbs and then with the chains on it would push snow straight ahead but if I angeled the blade it would just push the front of the tractor across the drive.We are getting ready to close on the house in November, so the mower is back on my mind as I haven't purchased anything yet. Thanks for all the responses. I wanted to clarify a few things that have come up.
The property is six total acres, all flat. It is basically a 2 acre by 3 acre rectangle with a drive cutting to a house in the middle of the lot. Some trees, but plenty of room to mow around them. With the exception of 8 fruit trees that are pretty close and will need some careful manuevering. Maybe a little push mowing in this area.
I was leaning towards the jdz465 when an interesting alternative presented itself. A friend has a jd x485 gt with 60" deck and 54" plow for sale for $5,000. His son works in the jd service dept and this thing is an immaculate 2002 with 700 hours. So the new z465 zero turn is the same price as a used x485 gt. I have enjoyed the discussion about
the benefits of a gt, especially with the long drive which will need snow removed this winter.
Any suggestions? Is $5,000 a fair price for the x485?
I appreciate the feedback.
jmac1 said:Do you really think the zero turn saves that much time vs a tractor? I've never mowed with a ztr so I am seriously asking. Even when we are comparing the same size deck - 60"? Is it because you can mow at a higher speed?
Do you really think the zero turn saves that much time vs a tractor? I've never mowed with a ztr so I am seriously asking. Even when we are comparing the same size deck - 60"? Is it because you can mow at a higher speed?
I will definitely include some pictures when I make a purchase.
While the property is currently 6 acres of grass right now, we do want to fence off part of it for some livestock. We'll start with a few pigs this spring and graduate to a steer or two in a year or so. I was talking with a farmer friend last night who said I'd probably come out ahead if I fenced off an acre or two. Plus we want a large garden...
And I'm not retired...34 with four kids...that is the reason for the house with acreage. I want our 3 boys to be boys. We live in town now, and I want them to have room to ride their bikes, have a go-cart, learn to care for livestock, etc. My wife grew up on a dairy farm, and wants to get back to the "country".
So with that said, I think the garden tractor would be put to good use over time. We could add a Johnny Bucket, a hydro tiller, the possibilities (and $$ to spend) seem endless. But I could also go with the ZTR and add a cheaper GT that would serve my needs well. I'm certainly not buying it to spend 8 hours a week on a mower.
Thanks again for all of the feedback and thoughts. This is a great forum! I'll make my decision soon!
..., why would Scag specifically state in their faq section that the zt is, by design, prone to damaging turf and that even very tight turns (not zero turns) have a great potential to damage the grass- ...
I did 'learn' how to stop putting union labels all over my yard by making the recommended 'T' turn
...no average homeowner will save a significant amount of time by using a zt over a quality LT/GT. Additionally I am convinced that any larger property owner would make a huge mistake by buying a zt over a cut as the single purchase. Not only will the cut offer more capability than any zt but will mow in just about the same amount of time as any zt-this cannot be intelligently disputed.
A quality LT/GT or cut is the better choice for anyone other than a pro, this type of machine offers far better comfort and safety; add in the additional capabilities
....
6 acres isn't enough land for livestock
KennyV, its important for everyone thinking about purchasing a zero turn mower to understand the limitations of this design; and the biggest myth that must be put to rest is that ANYONE can make a zero turn on turf without causing damage to the grass.....have you read the info on the Scag site?, or for that matter have you read the info about engine applications in zero turn mowers on the Briggs site??
I will admit that for individuals in your situation a zero turn is good to have in the stable, but for those of us unable to have more than one machine a zero turn is dumb, real dumb.
The people in Europe get all the good stuff
John Deere X749 Ultimate Diesel with Westa Type 450 snowblower (heavy snow) - YouTube
Robert this is a stupid comment clearly you don't understand how these thing work.jenkinsph, I believe that the 749 would be an excellent match for the op-many here cite the ability of zt's to accept accessories. I know my Exmark was very limited as to towing, I believe it was a 200lb max limit on the hitch, knowing this I suspect that most zt's are in the same ballpark. Some here maintain that the Grasshopper can do all sorts of things and there are many accessories for this machine and while there are alot of very expensive attachments for the GH I was curious as to what these can tow-would you believe that the official guideline is to tow with this machine only the load you can move by hand :laughing: big bucks for a machine that should not even tow a consumer lawn vac with I wonder if any of the zt crowd here knows just how little weight the unitized and pump/motor drives are rated for....?
I don't know anything about snow removal, but it seems to me that John Deere has all that it wants with that job.
Black Bart said:Robert my Grasshopper would pull you CC tractor back-wards and never slip a wheel.
It has bigger drive tires and weighs more than twice as much as your CC
Just buy one of each. :biggrin:
BlackBart, please stop the nonsense; TSC does not handle the Cub 2000 series, perhaps when you took a look it was still too soon after finishing mowing with your Grasshopper zt and your mind had not clear up yet from bouncing around on that zippidy doo dah....a 1 can look alot like a 2 after all.
Are your shorts all in a twist because you have confirmed that your mega dollar Grasshopper can't tow squat? :laughing:
I would add that if I could afford a Grasshopper, I think I would go that route. My problem is that for my $5,000 budget, they all have unbelievable hours on them (like well over 1,000). At least the ones I've seen for sale.
Bart - If you had $5,000 and wanted a 60" deck, would you buy a new JD Z465 or a Grasshopper (not sure on models) with 1,000+ hours?
I would add that if I could afford a Grasshopper, I think I would go that route. My problem is that for my $5,000 budget, they all have unbelievable hours on them (like well over 1,000). At least the ones I've seen for sale.
Bart - If you had $5,000 and wanted a 60" deck, would you buy a new JD Z465 or a Grasshopper (not sure on models) with 1,000+ hours?
Down through the years we added another garage a greenhouse and several flower gardens.
This changed things I have several places that the 12 foot long grasshopper won't turn in so I had to do these places with a hand mower.
robert said:Parkmower, please do everyone who is considering the purchase of a zt the favor of commenting on Scag's position that the zt design is inherently prone to turf damage and Briggs position that the zt application is the most hostile to any engine. Then, if you would be so kind, please comment on the towing capacity and the weight limits of the unitized drives, they are all about the same..
Then lets talk about internal drive temps on unitized drives with very small amounts of lube and differential drives with six or so quarts of lube, about the maint involved with those zt's that have motors and a pump with all the plumbing, about the many zero turns that don't even use a cooling fan on the drives, about operational noise, which engines stay cleaner from dust and debris, which design can tow more; in general lets talk about the things that really matter....for the average homeowner that is.
I am citing facts-direct from manufacturers and my own experience- you and a few others here are posting on pure emotion and this is where you are doing a huge disservice to all that are following this thread.
I hope you good luck on the pigs. The first year I raised them I had very good luck with them, but not the second year. I had a lot of enjoyment doing it.. They would eat just about anything. They would get all my grass clippings and what was left over from my garden and every else's garden I knew. I also would go to a dairy farm and feed them their left over bad milk, they just loved it. Another place I found food for them I would ask a farmer after they would harvest a field of corn if I could pick the left overs which I did. The problem started the second year. The first problem was that I used the same pen over from the first year and we have a wet summer. The pen just turned into a mud pit and I just couldn't do anything for the poor animals. I tryed straw just to dry it up but nothing worked and i put some concrete in just so they could get out of the mud. The only dry place for the was inside the hut I made for them. The second problem I had was when the rats came. This was too much and the last of my pig raising. I only thing I hate more then snakes is rats. So when you make your pen make sure it is on good high dry drained land and try to keep all food cleaned up and sealed. Good luckWow, this has become quite the heated forum here.
2. I'm not talking about going in the livestock business. Just a few animals. 2 pigs take no room at all, a 20' x 20' pen with a little homemade shelter/cover gets the job done no problem. Buy 'em in April, sell 'em at the fair in July...I'm not worried here. You are right cattle are more difficult and typically take two years, but still one or two cattle are fine on less than an acre. You don't want them running around anyway, they get too much muscle that way. I guess my point is, we have plenty of land for what we plan on doing. My wife grew up farming and we have her whole family advising us on this little endeavor. If it ever gets too much, we just don't buy animals that year. I think it will be fun...and less mowing
Still haven't made a decision yet...weighing lots of options...but I am enjoying the suggestions!
I have seen in other posts where you say your 725 mower is 12' long.
Mine is only about 9 foot long with the 61" deck.
What makes your's 3 foot longer ?
I have the 727K.
I hope you good luck on the pigs. The first year I raised them I had very good luck with them, but not the second year. I had a lot of enjoyment doing it.. They would eat just about anything. They would get all my grass clippings and what was left over from my garden and every else's garden I knew. I also would go to a dairy farm and feed them their left over bad milk, they just loved it. Another place I found food for them I would ask a farmer after they would harvest a field of corn if I could pick the left overs which I did. The problem started the second year. The first problem was that I used the same pen over from the first year and we have a wet summer. The pen just turned into a mud pit and I just couldn't do anything for the poor animals. I tryed straw just to dry it up but nothing worked and i put some concrete in just so they could get out of the mud. The only dry place for the was inside the hut I made for them. The second problem I had was when the rats came. This was too much and the last of my pig raising. I only thing I hate more then snakes is rats. So when you make your pen make sure it is on good high dry drained land and try to keep all food cleaned up and sealed. Good luck
What I hope that all who are thinking of purchasing a zt have learned from this thread:
A major maker of zero turn mowers states,on their website, that the design is prone to turf damage unless a very deliberate turning process is used.
A very major maker of engines for the industry state, on their website, that the zero turn application is very hostile to the engine because, unlike the tractor (this is also mentioned by this giant of a manufacturer) which adds-by design- significant protection from abrasive/heat increasing debris.
A major maker of pricey zero turns, Grasshopper, responded to an email from me in which I inquired as to the towing capacity of their excellent mowers-the answer was damage to the drive was a concern if any owner towed a weight which was greater than what any owner -could move by hand (by the way the most 'vocal' advocate of this brand now admitts that using a JD lawn/garden tractor is FASTER on his average homeowner sized yard)
The lawn or garden tractor is by far, the best choice for ANY homeowner. The machine is safer, more comfortable, will do more, and will be longer lived than a similar quality zero turn-these statements cannot be intelligently refuted.
As to point of purchase remember this; only one maker-John Deere, offers a thirty day return on the purchase of a tractor, confirm that the product which you are interested in is included. As for the big box stores, the evil big box stores, they also offer a thirty day return period, or at least they do in my area, you perhaps should keep this in mind OR ask your local power equipment dealer if they will give you an extended demo or a purchase with return privledges.
Lastly remember that all of the most vocal defenders of the homeowner zero turn purchase have steadfastly refused to comment on what Scag and Briggs and Stratton post on their own website regarding info relative to this thread choosing instead to assign these thoughts to me.
In the end a zero turn will make zero sense-it did for me and it will for you.
Robert,
... definitely leaning towards the ZT. Every commercial mowing place seems to favor the ZT's, and obviously they want to get their job done ASAP. Time=money...especially to them.
I thought you did mine has the water cooled kubota it is much longer also have a 72" deck it is bigger both in length and width.
I also have the collection system and the metal box hangs out behind the rear wheels.
I knew your deck added a few inch's, but I did not know you had the collection box on the back. My nephew has that on his Z-turn. When I have used his mower, the box seems to get in the way when I make turns, can't swing around as easy as one without a box.
KennyV, too bad that all he will be able to do is mow, and really not all that fast when he 'learns' the proper way because it will no longer really be a zero turn anymore will it?
Will you perhaps care to comment on what Scag and Briggs say about the zero turn?
This place is full of people who have developed a terminal case of 'factophobia'.
Robert,
I try to respect everyones opinion, I like GT's too and have been satisfied with mine, but man you need to let this go. This really disrupts the OP's thread which isn't fair or polite.
...-WHO is being impolite and unfair?