In the snowmobile world, to get a clutch off a tapered shaft would have you turn the sled on its side with the clutch up and center bolt removed. Fill the cavity with oil about 7/8ths full, grease the threads of the bolt, screw it back in as tight as it will go and smack the bolt head with a small hammer. Hydraulic shock pops it off every time.One more thing to try is after the penetrating oil, is to put the puller on the pulley with just enough pull to keep from bending the pulley. FIRST thread a bolt into the shaft, one long enough to hit bottom to protect the threads. The tap the bolt head with a hammer. The bolt will protect the shaft from damage. Do I have experience? I once pulled the bull sprocket from a 1942 Bucyrus-Erie drag-line. I had to borrow a heavy duty hydraulic puller from the US Army. We hid under the dragline as I pumped the puller to 5000 psi before it popped. We hid the under the dragline after reaching 1000 psi, but when it popped it was just a little dink that moved the sprocket about a quarter inch, but it was free!
Probably wouldn't work on a:
1942 Bucyrus-Erie drag-line