Troybilt Superbronco 46 inch deck with 20 HP Kohler Courage - massive oil leak

[jbeazell]

Blue locktit is what the factory fits and blue will do.
If you use red you need to heat the cases before you try to remove the bolts.
You may have worn the front threads to the point that they will not hold when hot so either helicoil the 4 front ones or go up to a larger size bolt.
IF you want to make it a NASCAR mower you can always drill the bolt heads and fit lockwire

I'd love to lock wire it, but I'm not that good at doing those things

Any suggestions for keeping those bolts in place.. like SERIOUSLY in place. I'm thinking of the nuclear option like taking the bad boy somewhere to have them all tig welded in place. The bolts I took out were fine (except the ONE). It looked like the red locktite just pooled at the top and didn't sink into the thread bores. Each bolt hole had a perfect little red ring at the top before the threads started. I'm already committed to getting a new one and selling this thing for junk, soon. It couldn't even make it through an hour and a half mow without falling apart and those bolt coming out, again. I'm not going to stop every 30 minutes to tear it down and re-torque those bolts.

 

[bertsmobile1]

If the top plate is flogged oval where the bolts went through, you might need to replace it.
This was required on a couple .
Some that came i the bolts had been backed out that far for that long the flywheel had ground off the heads.
Did you check with Kohler ?
Other than locktite you might need to fit heli coils or upsize to bigger bolts.

Other than that decide if the mower is worth a replacement engine.

Vibrations are funny things.
One customer had a 2' long crack that they said had been there since new and just weeped a bit.
Others can be fine then split that far in a single mow that the fuel pump no longer worked

 

[jbeazell]

Other than that decide if the mower is worth a replacement engine.

that's the question of the day. I got it used, and only really wanted it to last a season. It seems to give me issues every other mow. One thing here, one thing there, and most of them are small annoying things, but enough to make me have to split my mowing into two days. I have a post earlier about the drive system not working, and some helpful soul got that sorted for me (thank you to whoever that was!). It's been the plan to replace it this spring, but I don't know if I'll be able to keep it hobbling until then. A replacement motor is tempting to see if I can stretch it out until spring 2020, but I doubt it. I have a feeling that more stupid little things will keep popping up.

I got it cheap, and I expected to do work on it to keep it going. I don't think spending more on an engine than I spent on the entire thing is worth it I'm not sure I can trust a Craigslist engine

I tried to contact Kolher, but I haven't gotten anything back from them. the engine was assembled in 2007, and I'm not the original buyer.

 

[jbeazell]

thanks for all the help. I looked a bit closer at the top plate, and sure enough, all the front bolt holes are ovaled. Some have actual impact fractures in the metal around the hole! That must be one hell of a vibration to cause something like that. No wonder those things are walking lose. I doubt there is much I can do at this point. I suspect that anything I do will just end up with the things coming lose again, the gasket becoming useless again, and the crack getting bigger. I could try the helicoil route, but I don't know if that'll do anything either.

On another note, when I grab the crankshaft housing... uh... thing that hangs off the crankshaft (It's not a counter balance because it doesn't move--- it's just a large hunk of metal) , I can move it around inside the block.

I know the top bearing isn't there to help hold it down, but that just doesn't seem right Is the bottom bearing (for lack of a better term since there is no bearing) being out of tolerance causing this vibration and breakdown of the engine?

 

[bertsmobile1]

When the bottom bush area is flogged out it chews the lower seal out very quickly then dumps a lot of oil.
The top plates are a replacement item and it has to be in good condition.

I have looked at these engines and the guess is they were designed for a forged steel crank ( as fitted to the command series ) and then some wit at board level said "No too expensive use a cast one "
THe casting is weaker so has to be bigger there fore heavier and requires a heavier counter weight to smooth things out ,
It is a shame because it was otherwise a very well designed engine

 

[jbeazell]

thanks for your help on this

another totally random question, but how easy is it to fit another engine on there? The chassis looks like it has a bunch of engine mounting holes under the engine. how much do new standalone engines typically go for (southeast US region).

 

[jbeazell]

Also, I got word from Kohler that they are STILL honoring the warranty for the engine! That's pretty amazing. Only problem is that it is for the original owner, which I'm not They asked me to bring the tractor and a copy of my original receipt to an authorized dealer

I'm going to head over to the close one to see what they say about things. I have no idea where that will lead, but I'd hate to just toss this thing. The rest of it is pretty OK

 

[bertsmobile1]

thanks for your help on this

another totally random question, but how easy is it to fit another engine on there? The chassis looks like it has a bunch of engine mounting holes under the engine. how much do new standalone engines typically go for (southeast US region).

Any new residential Kohler engine will drop right in and plug up.
Older ones might need a bit of electricals if they are fitted with one of the fancy ignitions ( more than 1 small wire on the coils )

Any domestic Briggs will fit as the mower was originally fitted with Briggs as an option but will require a modicum of rewiring, not plug & play.
Kawakasi engines should also go in but you have to watch the size of the PTO shaft, it is a bit harder to work out from the engine numbers if they have 1" or 1.125"
Lots of cheap engines available from surplus stores this time of year as mower making winds down

 

[jbeazell]

So, I put it all back together, and I locktited AND JB welded the front bolts so that they wouldn't come out. I figured that if this engine was that far gone, I don't care about drilling them out if I need to get back in there. I mowed for about 20 minutes and looked, and the entire front gasket had again puked itself back out the front cover, and it was seeping oil, again. The bolts, however, had not moved. I marked them. They stayed put, but the gasket didn't. So, I kept going until I ran out of gas about an hour later.

That night, I pulled out and cut out as much of the gasket as I could get to. I didn't want to break my hulk hold on those bolts, so I left them there. I put a bunch of JB weld into the crack between the cover and the block where the gasket was. Maybe that wasn't a great idea.

This morning, with fresh gas, I went to finish off about 20 minutes of mowing. I started it up and drove about 60 feet, and CRUNK-a-thunk thunk thunk. It threw a rod and scared the **** out of me. That was seriously loud.

Maybe it was just it's time with as much vibration as was going on. Maybe a hunk of JB weld came off and got into something it shouldn't. I can't imagine that JB weld would actually DO anything that quickly. I would imagine that if anything, it'd get broken down into smaller pieces that MIGHT Impede oil flow somewhere... maybe.. but then it'd have to get through the oil filter?

anyway, this engine is gone. I'll tear it down and take some photos if anybody cares to see the carnage.

 

[bertsmobile1]

Bummer