As a follow up, I completed this job, using the gasket, day before yesterday. The old gasket was very brittle, and you could see where it was compromised around the locating pin near the oil filter. Started up with no issues and no leaks so far. It looks like Kohler has been changing things, probably trying to address this problem. I found reference on YT to a Kohler part number 24 041 54-S which was packaged with the gasket and a new, solid locating pin. This part number has been superseded by 24 041 66-S which is packaged with the gasket and an O-ring (and no locating pin). When I looked at the manual, it shows the rtv application pattern going around an O-ring, and also filling a "groove" between 2 points on the casting. My engine had no groove, and no seat for the O'ring. I asked the part dealer for a solid locating pin, but they didn't stock ANY of the locating pins. What pushed me over the edge to go back with the gasket was reading about all the color coded shims available to achieve proper clearances. I feared exactly what Rain today mentioned in his post above. Thanks so much for all the input from everyone.