Problem fixed!!
Father-in-law came over with a battery recharger and all his automotive knowledge, experience and had the problem fixed in 5 minutes.
Basically, 2 problems:
1) Main problems: Battery terminals too corroded. I hadn't isolated this problem b/c of:
2) The clutch/brake safety switch was slightly off. It took a few jiggling/pushes on the clutch pedal to release the safety switch.
At that point we could sometimes crank engine using the battery charger but with obvious arc + sparks.
At that point, I took apart the + lead from my battery and cleaned it out with a toothbrush and baking soda. Got rid of all the gunk and put it back.
Charged the battery for good measure for a couple of hours using the loaner charger and then tried again: perfect start without hesitation.
Lucky it was such a simple problem. Wish I'd followed the advice I saw somewhere to look at the corrosion 1st but the clutch safety switch tricked me.
It is possible that a new clutch/brake safety switch lies in my near future sometime but for now the tractor is back in working order.
Thanks to everyone - I've learned a lot about my tractor even though I still don't have a good circuit diagram and/or repair manual!!
Cheers,
-Alex