Any play in a pulley is not normal. It should be tight and sound smooth when you spin it. Just keep an eye on it and replace as needed.It is Part # 483422, approx 1/18" side play, normal or not ? Only the one pulley.. May be beginning of very slight noise down there.
Only has 58 hours on it.
I will check all 3 idlers for smoothness & noise soon..I tend to pay more attention to smoothness when turning and noise than I do slop. Have had too many pulleys that wiggle, thinking the bearing is going bad, and find that the new OEM pulley has more slop then the one you are thinking about replacing.
Certainly not a water contamination issue, as I have never had water near it, not even rain.So there could be a shockload or maybe even a water contamination issue with the deck bearings.
The motion drive ones here I having to replace a lot is the 2" ones of Hustler ZTRs. Due to their size they are being over sped and grease is vanishing from them so they run dry and destroy the bearings. On these whenever replacing the drive belt the idler should be replaced too.Deck bearings both in the idlers and the spindles seem to be hit and miss as far as longevity. Had a Yardman years ago that I had to replace all three deck spindles under warranty on a less than 1 month old mower due to deck vibration from the spindles would make your feet tingle within seconds of kicking on the blades. Don't see as many issues with the idlers on the motion drive belts. So there could be a shockload or maybe even a water contamination issue with the deck bearings.