I don't understand what you doing when you say jumped from starter? What did the shop test, not under a load? What are you testing at Advance Auto, the battery?
When I pull a flywheel I use a puller, but in a pinch I have pulled flywheels by prying under the fly and hitting the top of the crankshaft with a hammer and punch, but if you do it this way use caution because you can do damage.