Good stuff gets repeated. Sure wish this site would just create a few stickies on basics, including battery. Anyway ...
I have bought the 230AMP rider batteries for years and have them in 3 cars, right, 3 cars for weight reduction. Yes. this is not for most as these guys are sensitive to frequent starts. I run them year round including winter , here usually 25F-above. The point? They last if maintained, and have lasted the 2-3 years expected in cars and riders (lots of ruts.) I do cater to them, $25 new.
As Bert mentioned there are many good sites to help understand batteries. No one above mentioned (?) the use of bat hydrometers as a supplementary device which is cheap ($10) and can help reach conclusions . If one of the batteries is aged or otherwise suspect I use the hydrometer to measure the specific gravity after charging. Recently I got a hydrometer with a finer scale, not just "good", "fair", "bad" ( the little floats that rise when you draw out the electrolyte with the suction bulb have numbers on them). And I now use the ground rule of "50 points." As you check across the 6 cells note the readings. Variation of .50 across the 6 readings indicates a failed battery . This is also useful if you have a "repair" or "desulfate" function on your charger which may say "repaired" battery and read 12.8 v or above, but which registers a 50 point spread on the hydrometer. Recently this drill showed a failed battery which would not hold the 12.8v over a minute.