Fixed!!
A local machinist cut the other teeth down then brazed a new sprocket onto it. He had a little shaping to do on the teeth. He said the existing metal was infused with oil and couldn't be welded properly. Said it was a challenge but he enjoyed it. Thanks to the group for the input. Now for the assembly.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/45780/45780cd02255d225a6a9232b58b9fce31711e5ba" alt="Gear, fixed by Bill B 2.2.jpg Gear, fixed by Bill B 2.2.jpg"