Lot going on here that the OP will have to address. re date code on his engine - 04052QZA - the date code if goofy unless the Q is a 0 in which case the manufacture date would be May 20, 2004. If so the way I read the Briggs fiche, the flywheel part number should be 595100 because it was made prior to July 2012. Someone can verify that but it is how I read it. (I think the OP updated the part number later in the thread to the same.) The casting number on the part itself is not always the Briggs part number. Probably used from a salvage yard or Ebay is all that will be available if one of the others doesn't fit. As to whether the ones off the alternate engines there will fit, that depends on the date codes of those engines which were not provided. Have to go to the fiche for those engines and look up the flywheel PART number. The casting number on the flywheel can fool.
yes. It just isn't getting a good mesh. Pretty rusty too. Bendix might be compromised but the distance between gears is also not right.
View attachment 74971
Also - the gear is all the way up in the photo. Doesn't the gear drop back when it is not spinning on this model starter? The photo below also shows a gap on the opposite side of the armature shaft - As if there is a lot of play in the gear and shaft. To me, it looks like the starter needs work or replacement. It's possible it simply stayed engaged and wore the flywheel out. Lack of maintenance is the culprit here me thinks.
View attachment 74972