Most likely the numbers on the crank are casting numbers, so unless you have the casting codes they mean nothing. Are both the slots on the crank, for the timing gear the same? Do the timing gear align at the same point? Do you have a vernier caliper to measure the thrust surfaces to see if the are the same? Sorry for all the questions, but I’m not standing next to you with a strong drink in hand to see what you have. I’m thinking you may not have matching cranks, or the counterbalance does not match.