The part number of the replacement deck may prove to be very very important. MTD is known for doing running changes on replacement parts, and the only thing that may resemble the old part is the fact that it fits the mower. You may have a service replacement deck that uses a different parts diagram than your original deck, so your parts diagram won't work.
Tried doing a deck replacement shell on a cub cadet a few years ago, and after getting the new shell discovered that absolutely none, and I mean none of the parts would fit from the old deck.
I used to have a belt tool 20yrs ago but it was in one of my tool boxes that was stolen from my van.That sounds like the 46" cut "H" decks here where they came with 103" belts but after a few years the same decks needs to be switch over to 102" belts. I got 4 of those decks that are now running the 102" belts.
On 104" being put on I had Stens send me supposedly 103" belts but they came in at 104". This why I have 200" v-belt measuring tool now.
so you do't have a 1 yard / 1 meter steel rule ?I used to have a belt tool 20yrs ago but it was in one of my tool boxes that was stolen from my van.
I wish I had it measured, I saw 96", 104" & 103" stated for this MTD belt length when looking it up? That old belt may have just stretched enough to fall off but 2 seasons is awful fast for as big as it was? May been marked wrong at factory & both belts are supposed to be 96" but Im not sure myself?
Ive not measured a new belt in yrs but Im not surprised you found different sized stens belts since quality control has never been they're strong point.
Why I love my old Wheel Horse decks belt design. It has about 5" of belt adjustment with a turn of a hand knob on front so this amount wouldnt even matter on it.
But I bet it is wrong when the belt has a six piece missing as to the correct length of the original belt.Well what can I say
My work shop is exactly the same to the point that most work is done outside
Buta long steel rule is very cheap and hangs on a nail so not a big investment and is never wrong even with a broken belt .