Export thread

Recomendation Needed: Lawn Tractor for 1/2+ acre

#1

R

redrob2

I just moved into a new place and need my first lawn tractor/mower. The job is simple - Mow & Tow (once and a while). I've looked at the JD D125 and D130, as well as the Husky YTH22V46. They seem fine but I hear bad things about all mowers. Is there one I'm missing? $1800 is probably the top of my range and don't think I need to go any higher to do what I need the tractor to do. I'd love some recommendations as I've scoured many reviews and feel like I'm just losing my mind at this point with all of the conflicting stories. Every one seems to have a different issue or problem. Love to hear from you guys. Thanks in advance!


#2

Carscw

Carscw

redrob2 said:
I just moved into a new place and need my first lawn tractor/mower. The job is simple - Mow & Tow (once and a while). I've looked at the JD D125 and D130, as well as the Husky YTH22V46. They seem fine but I hear bad things about all mowers. Is there one I'm missing? $1800 is probably the top of my range and don't think I need to go any higher to do what I need the tractor to do. I'd love some recommendations as I've scoured many reviews and feel like I'm just losing my mind at this point with all of the conflicting stories. Every one seems to have a different issue or problem. Love to hear from you guys. Thanks in advance!
Click to expand...

Cub cadet ltx1040.


#3

J

JPDVM2014

I joined to ask this exact question. I've come to the same problem. Apparently all tractors aren't very good until you are up into the $3k range. :smile: I've narrowed it down to the JD D125 or the Husqvarna YTH18K46. I'm leaning towards the husky since a friend of mine has one and likes it, plus i can borrow his attachments.


#4

Carscw

Carscw

JPDVM2014 said:
I joined to ask this exact question. I've come to the same problem. Apparently all tractors aren't very good until you are up into the $3k range. :smile: I've narrowed it down to the JD D125 or the Husqvarna YTH18K46. I'm leaning towards the husky since a friend of mine has one and likes it, plus i can borrow his attachments.
Click to expand...


The husqvarna is a better built tractor then the JD

Have you looked at cub cadet?

I think for the price range you looking at they are the best mower for the money.

I like my husqvarna yth2448

I buy a new mower every year last year was a cub cadet. I put over 1000 hours on it never replaced drive belts. Sold it last month for $750. Still ran and cut like new.


#5

J

JPDVM2014

redrob, I didn't mean to hijack the thread, but since we are looking for essentially the same thing (mowers, price range, acreage) I figure it's better to have the discussion in one place. Anyway. I haven't really looked at the Cub Cadets. The only reason is that I have found more negative reviews of them than the other two. A lot of people say they aren't as good as they used to be. Obviously, your experience is different. I'll have to revisit them since the Cub Cadet dealer is actually quite a bit closer than the others, so bringing it in for repairs would be easier.


#6

Carscw

Carscw

JPDVM2014 said:
redrob, I didn't mean to hijack the thread, but since we are looking for essentially the same thing (mowers, price range, acreage) I figure it's better to have the discussion in one place. Anyway. I haven't really looked at the Cub Cadets. The only reason is that I have found more negative reviews of them than the other two. A lot of people say they aren't as good as they used to be. Obviously, your experience is different. I'll have to revisit them since the Cub Cadet dealer is actually quite a bit closer than the others, so bringing it in for repairs would be easier.
Click to expand...

Remember the thing with reading reviews is the people that like the mower don't come back to say they do.

The only thing I needed to replace was spindle bearings a couple times. But almost every mower brand uses the same bearing.

I am very hard on mowers I run them fast.
last summer I was cutting 70 to 100 yards a week. Around 20 a week would be over a foot tall.

My brother in laws jd would not keep up.

You can't go wrong with the cub cadet or the husqvarna. Made by two different company's but both will handle abuse


#7

djdicetn

djdicetn

JPDVM2014 said:
redrob, I didn't mean to hijack the thread, but since we are looking for essentially the same thing (mowers, price range, acreage) I figure it's better to have the discussion in one place. Anyway. I haven't really looked at the Cub Cadets. The only reason is that I have found more negative reviews of them than the other two. A lot of people say they aren't as good as they used to be. Obviously, your experience is different. I'll have to revisit them since the Cub Cadet dealer is actually quite a bit closer than the others, so bringing it in for repairs would be easier.
Click to expand...

I would stay away from the Cub Cadets at big box retailers like Home Depot. The ones you can get at a CC dealer are much better quality. I consider Husqvarna's one of the best bang-for-your-buck lawn tractor out there. If you can afford it, the YT48XLS(approx. $2,899) is a beast of a lawn tractor with a fabricated/welded deck(very rare on a lt), hydro tranny with locking differential and Kawasaki FR series engine!!! It has a very good warranty(3 year, with a 5 year chassis & axle and lifetime deck) which tend to make it worth the extra money. That's what I would buy if I were wanting a current lawn tractor offering.


#8

R

redrob2

Well thanks for the update guys. I've always leaned towards the Husky but my dad who is usually pretty good with this stuff looked it and the JD and felt like some parts on the Husky were cheaper than the JD so I started leaning away from it. From the sounds of it though it has a pretty good reputation. I haven't looked at the Cadets yet, might be time to look at them as well. Boy, so many choices! Thanks again for all the help and advice. If there are more out there keep 'em coming!


#9

R

redrob2

Just went ant took a look at the Husky and the Cub Cadet LTX1045. I really liked the Cub and was in the same boat of others on here saying they didn't look at them much because of the reviews. Seemed like a really solid machine and slightly easier maintenance than the Husky. Any reason to get the 1040 over the 1045 for only $100 difference? Seems like a no brainer for the little bit of extra cash. Tell me otherwise though!


#10

Carscw

Carscw

redrob2 said:
Just went ant took a look at the Husky and the Cub Cadet LTX1045. I really liked the Cub and was in the same boat of others on here saying they didn't look at them much because of the reviews. Seemed like a really solid machine and slightly easier maintenance than the Husky. Any reason to get the 1040 over the 1045 for only $100 difference? Seems like a no brainer for the little bit of extra cash. Tell me otherwise though!
Click to expand...

They are really both the same so do you want a 42 or a 46 inch deck.

What I like is the welded frame and cast iron Front axle. And the two steering arms better then one arm and a tie rod.
And don't forget the 10 gauge deck and the 4 anti scalp wheels.


#11

Carscw

Carscw

Just don't get a junk Deere in this price range. You over pay for a name and a cheaper built mower


#12

R

redrob2

No Deere for me. Going to get the 1045 I think. Just saw the 4 antiscalp wheels which is a nice bonus. Any reason to but at a tractor supply store over HD? Probably a crap shoot at either place.


#13

Carscw

Carscw

redrob2 said:
No Deere for me. Going to get the 1045 I think. Just saw the 4 antiscalp wheels which is a nice bonus. Any reason to but at a tractor supply store over HD? Probably a crap shoot at either place.
Click to expand...

I would buy at tractor supply they take the time to set it up and can give you more info.
Or a dealer would be even better.

I find that the people that work at Home Depot just piss me off.

The 4 anti scalp wheels are a must for me.


#14

L

LoCo86

Carscw said:
I would buy at tractor supply they take the time to set it up and can give you more info. Or a dealer would be even better. I find that the people that work at Home Depot just piss me off. The 4 anti scalp wheels are a must for me.
Click to expand...

I agree most of the time at Home Depot it's just someone who is working part time hurrying up the assembly process to get to their lunch break. A dealer would be better but like you say of you don't have one near you then Tractor Supply would be your best bet.


#15

J

JPDVM2014

What is the attachment capabilities of these tractors? Is it pretty much just a dump cart, or would they handle a dethatcher and/or aerator. I think I already know the answer to this, but what about light snow plowing? If they aren't able to handle an aerator or dethatcher, what would be the model that could? $1,800 is already kind of pushing my budget, but if there is a model that will do more for a little bit of a premium, I would be willing to spend the extra money.


#16

Carscw

Carscw

JPDVM2014 said:
What is the attachment capabilities of these tractors? Is it pretty much just a dump cart, or would they handle a dethatcher and/or aerator. I think I already know the answer to this, but what about light snow plowing? If they aren't able to handle an aerator or dethatcher, what would be the model that could? $1,800 is already kind of pushing my budget, but if there is a model that will do more for a little bit of a premium, I would be willing to spend the extra money.
Click to expand...

The 1045 will handle it.
I do not plow snow but I do use the blade for doing my gravel driveway.


#17

R

redrob2

Well thanks for all the great advice. I went with the 1042KW and pick it up tomorrow. Can't wait to get it home and start having some fun!


#18

J

JPDVM2014

redrob2 said:
Well thanks for all the great advice. I went with the 1042KW and pick it up tomorrow. Can't wait to get it home and start having some fun!
Click to expand...

This is the one I'm going to get, if I go with Cub Cadet. I still haven't decided. :smile: I did test drive my friend's Husky this past weekend though, and it is a sweet machine.


#19

Carscw

Carscw

JPDVM2014 said:
This is the one I'm going to get, if I go with Cub Cadet. I still haven't decided. :smile: I did test drive my friend's Husky this past weekend though, and it is a sweet machine.
Click to expand...

You can not go wrong with the cub or the husqvarna.


Footer Links 1

Top