Hello everyone!
Currently I'm using John Deere 318 with 46 inch deck to mow my 3/4 acre lot. It' pretty flat with a considerable hill on one side(I have to tilt my body sideways and tractor almost slips down..). No issues with scalping but I don't like how it cuts.
When I bought this tractor (4 years ago) I was thinking that I will use it for other stuff, I had snow blade which I sold and I had pull behind card which I also sold. I also tried pull-behind sweeper and didn't like it too much (for leafs). I'm using back pack blower for leafs and tractor for mowing. Now I'm just cutting grass with a tractor and don't really care about how it works. My neighbors use professional service and their grass looks much better. I see those guys doing it faster and seems like those professional stand-behind mowers mulch very good (mine leaves clippings even with good mulching blades). I also see those guys using same mowers during leaf season where they multch them and bag them into almost non-existent pile (my leaf pile is huge and takes 4 hours of non-stop blowing into piles)
Anyway. I can fix up older mower, not really looking into brand new expensive stuff. I can probably spend up to 2k, but less is better. I'd like to know what would be better. ZTR is more comfort, but wouldn't it be too big for my yard? Most guys who does it for living in our area use stand-behinds. Ideally it will help me with leafs. My main goal is to get best possible cutting ability in shortest time.
Any suggestions? I don't know what brands to look for, models? How many hours is too much?
It depends on what you're calling a stand up mower. Are you talking about a walk-behind with a sulky or a regular stand behind mower like a Toro Grandstand? The big problem as I see it is your budget. You may pick up a used residential ZTR for 2K but how good it will be and how many hours it will have would be anyone's guess and you cut may or may not be as good as what you're using now, it just depends on the quality of the ZTR.
<2k budget is just common sense. I can get someone cut my grass for $35 and purchase of $5k+ won't make much sense as I could probably pay for 10 years of service instead of buying good $5k machine.. I just checked full stand-ups and they look very good. But looks like out of my budget for sure So I guess I'm talking about "walk-behind with a sulky" vs "ZTR". On my JD 318 I rebuilt deck completely with new bearings, wheels, etc so I guess it cuts as good as it can. I see no problem doing the same for used ZTR/walk behind. I just don't know what machines I need to look at.
<2k budget is just common sense. I can get someone cut my grass for $35 and purchase of $5k+ won't make much sense as I could probably pay for 10 years of service instead of buying good $5k machine..
I just checked full stand-ups and they look very good. But looks like out of my budget for sure
So I guess I'm talking about "walk-behind with a sulky" vs "ZTR".
On my JD 318 I rebuilt deck completely with new bearings, wheels, etc so I guess it cuts as good as it can. I see no problem doing the same for used ZTR/walk behind. I just don't know what machines I need to look at.
So, commercial walk behinds cost as much as ZTR? I though they should be cheaper in general, no?
Which (in general) will be better at mulching and bagging? ZTR or walk behind?
With only 3/4 of an acre there may be a small deck (36 to 42" deck) commercial ztr in the 3 to 4k range.
Small deck ZTR sounds good to me. It will be easier to park and go around corners. I assume it won't be slower than current 46" deck just because of the way I can turn and move faster?
What about mulching ability? Will smaller decks do as good job?
Ok, then it looks like ZTR is what I need.. What is their footprint (parking)? My JD in 50 inch wide and 68 inch long. ZTRs look bigger, but I wonder if that is true.
What about hills? Can ZTR mower handle hills OK? Right now we have Z225 JD ZTR for sale at $2400 almost new. I assume this is residential model? How do I know the difference?
Would you say that 10yo commercial ZTR will be better (in proper work order) than new residential ZTR?
I know that deck on my JD is low speed and has bad suction, so many new things will do better. But I want to try and get best. I don't mind doing some restoration but need to know..
I'm taking this hill with my JD right now. Yes, I have to lean my body to the side but it works and doesn't feel like I'm close to tipping or anything like that. ZTR's at least LOOK like they have wider stance and planted better than my lawn tractor.
Doing or mowing a hill with a tractor is a lot different than doing it with a ZTR. Your weight is distributed differently on the tractor for one and you can steer a tractor with the front tires, not so with a ZTR. The ztr mowers that have been mentioned like the 36" or 42" are not going to have a much wider foot print, base or stance than your JD, for instance the Dixie chopper 42" cut is only 51" wide with the chute so the wheel base itself is going to be somewhat more narrow than that and a 36" ztr will be even smaller.
A ztr's weight is all in the back of the mower, the engine, the drives, wheels and yourself. Your front wheels or castors do nothing as far as having any control over the unit. If I were you and this may sound like over kill but for the money you want to spend I'd look into a Hustler Raptor 54" deck, the cost is like $2799 and it would last you forever.
Hustler Turf
Agree with your post. Except for the part about the raptor. I think hustlers are fine mowers, but the raptor is made a little too light in the back end to handle much of a hill. Would do everything else he wants well though.
It would sure handle the hill better and safer than what he is using now and he would sure get a better cut than the tractor. It would also be new with a warranty.
The hill that I'm talking about is like 25 degree (eyeballing..) but I don't drive "up", I take it sideways. And it takes 3 passes to mow it with my 46. It's straight line hill on a back of a lot.
I don't disagree that it would cut better. Hustler mowers are great products. I don't know what kind of hill he is talking about, but I do know the raptor doesn't have the trannys to handle much of a slope.
That's too steep for the raptor, but some dealer will let you test their product at your home. If you are interested in one then I suggest talking to your local dealer and see if they will let you try it out on your lawn before you buy. Test as many as you can before you buy. Ric is 100% correct that the raptor would give you the cut you are looking for. Any of the brands with a commercial deck will give you the cut quality.
I found some Raptor dealers around, will check them out. Where can I read on how ZTR's actually work? You talk about tranny, steering, etc. I know in my tractor I have hydraulic deck lift, I have separate hydrostatic tranny and power steering.
I have some wet spots in a yard, mowing them with a tractor done best if I move fast, I did get suck once... How is ZTR's in those "swampy" areas? What about cutting wet grass? I don't get into wet grass with my tractor, but I see pro's doing it just fine. Rarely I see clumps on my neighbours yards...
Ric is correct, this <3k Raptor is probably maximum I want to spend. They do 0% which is excellent too. Do those dealers negotiate like car dealers do? What kind of price off from MSRP I can expect?
Paying pro's to cut is basically every week. But I cut less(I think). When grass growing I might cut every 5 days or so and in a middle of summer I may cut once in 2 weeks. I use tractor 20hr per year MAX. I do think I may need bagger as well as it may help with leafs during a season.
Going little off-topic, what is the best preferred way to take care of leafs? I have big trees and as I mentioned takes 4hr non-stop blowing with backpack Makita (4 cycle) that I have. I blow leafs into piles and then use tarp to move them to the street. I see pros doing it both ways. Some people use blowers, but some use mowers, If it's done regularly (every week) than not much leafs left after cutting. Does that sound correct? Will I be able to do it with Raptor?
Thank you for this video link. At 6:25 they show slope that looks just like the one I have. Doesn't seem to be a problem at all..
I read online but is there any break-down on features that commercial ZTR might have and residentials don't? I understand deck construction, heavy duty engines, etc. But there is something about suspensions, different drive motors?
I always recommend that people test the product on their lawn before they buy if at all possible.
Thank you for this video link. At 6:25 they show slope that looks just like the one I have. Doesn't seem to be a problem at all..
I read online but is there any break-down on features that commercial ZTR might have and residentials don't? I understand deck construction, heavy duty engines, etc. But there is something about suspensions, different drive motors?
You need to understand that the mower used on that video is the z master series, which is a commercial mower. The raptor is nowhere near the mower as the ones on the video.
You need to understand that the mower used on that video is the z master series, which is a commercial mower. The raptor is nowhere near the mower as the ones on the video. The z master mowers are much heavier and have heavy duty commercial trannys. They have hydro gear zt3400 and zt 5400 trannys. The raptor only has zt2800 trannys. Make sure you know it will mow the hill before you purchase.
Thank you for this video link. At 6:25 they show slope that looks just like the one I have. Doesn't seem to be a problem at all..
I read online but is there any break-down on features that commercial ZTR might have and residentials don't? I understand deck construction, heavy duty engines, etc. But there is something about suspensions, different drive motors?
Took a picture of how this hill look like. Probably looks better than what it is, plus fence. I trip near fence anyway..
You can also see what my JD leaves..
View attachment 21998
The Raptor doesn't have the 2800 drives for FYI it has the EZT drives. The Raptor SD has the 2800 drive units which would last the residential operator a lifetime.
I don't cut it too low. Maybe I can cut more often, but I don't want to do it more often then every week. I know my cousin cut's twice with different depth settings to minimize clippings. I want to see no clippings And I don't want to cut twice. Blades is OK, this last cut I didn't notice that one of the wheels was almost out of air.
I am not a JD fan I think they are junk. But they cut better then what's in this pic.
It is not the mowers fault that you have clippings. And getting a zero turn is not going to fix things for you.
The pros that cut the yard make it look better then yours because they take pride in doing a good job.
I can see making a pass or two with a low tire and thinking I need to stop something is not right but you cut the whole yard.
IMO the mower is not to blame for the mess YOU have made of your yard.
And that is not a hill that is a slight incline.
Sorry if I hurt your feelings but someone had to say it.
Took a picture of how this hill look like. Probably looks better than what it is, plus fence. I trip near fence anyway..
You can also see what my JD leaves..
View attachment 21998
I am not a JD fan I think they are junk. But they cut better then what's in this pic.
It is not the mowers fault that you have clippings. And getting a zero turn is not going to fix things for you.
The pros that cut the yard make it look better then yours because they take pride in doing a good job.
I can see making a pass or two with a low tire and thinking I need to stop something is not right but you cut the whole yard.
IMO the mower is not to blame for the mess YOU have made of your yard.
And that is not a hill that is a slight incline.
Sorry if I hurt your feelings but someone had to say it.
You didn't hurt my feelings. Looks like wheel started to loose air when I was finishing cutting (back yard) so I didn't bother with it.
In beginning of a year when grass grows fast I have to mow in circles and manually rack and bag grass.
I've been dealing with this deck for 4 years so I know how it can cut. I have original JD blades and I have Gator blades. Deck is straight with all new bearings, belts, etc. If you do some research you fill find that this JD is from 1990 and this particular 46" deck does not have good suction. New JD tractors cut better, they have better designed decks and people upgrade those tractors with new 48 inch decks. I was thinking about this, but this new deck is $1200+ so I figured I'd rather go to dedicated mowing machine.
Someone has a nice fortress wall to keep Mongols at bay.Took a picture of how this hill look like. Probably looks better than what it is, plus fence. I trip near fence anyway.. You can also see what my JD leaves..
Just came back from dealer. Didn't drive machines, but sit in Raptor and Raptor SD. They only had RSD with 60" so I didn't see how 54 looks (what seat and wheels)
Dealer said that factory shut down right now, issues with powdercoating? They say RSD 54" is in high demand, have couple preordered and no date.
Just by looking at machines I will be choosing between Raptor 52" and RSD 54" On one hand RSD has 18900 blade speed vs 16700 in 52" Raptor, but I wonder how much it will affect cut. Other differences don't really bother me, I won't use it that much.
He also said that Kawasaki made here in Mussiouri and they were back logged. I wonder if all this issues with rush and demand will affect quality..
If I went with dealer I would get RSD.
But Raptors sold at big box stores now. With coupon and store cards I can buy 52" Raptor closer to $2k.
Decisions, decisions..
Funny video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O3ixg_yhEiA They show Raptor vs Tractor on a hill that's little bit bigger than what I have. I admit I do much better than guy on black tractor, but kudos to ZTR
*Disclaimer Hill was sprayed with water before the riding mower to produce morning dew like conditions* lol Also how he said "Rap-tore" in his accent made me smile for some reason.Are you kidding me? A riding mower would have no problem on that hill. But the ztr did good
I have about 13 hours on Raptor SD 54 and wanted to post a short review. All I can say is why I didn't get ZTR sooner. I had lawn tractor and it's night and day..
I had issue at beginning: http://www.lawnmowerforum.com/hustler-forum/28396-need-vent-about-new-raptor-sd.html
Now I installed mulch kit, heat shield and engine guard.
If you read my original post - I was impressed with how pro's handle my neighbours yards. Now my yard looks better! And I already saved tons of time. With mulch kit Raptor does excellent job. At first I had to scrape deck couple times after trying to cut wet or in a morning. Or when grass was growing fast. I was kind of hoping it will take care of leafs and it exceeded my expectations. Everybody blowing or collecting leafs this days, I used to do this too, it was taking me maybe 15hr of work every season with big backpack blower. Now it mulches so well that I have perfect lawn, rarely I need to do 2 passes. Leafs clipped to about 1/4 inch size and barely visible, you have to look for it to see. If I understand it right - it is good for the grass too. But final verdict on leafs will be in a spring when grass starts growing back.
I was worrying about hill - no problem. I feel very comfortable turning on a hill, going sideways, etc. It handles it very well.
Negative thing comparing to lawn tractor - ZTR uses much more gas.
I guess any decent ZTR would do this, but so far I'm really happy.
This sounds about right. Or maybe little more, hard to tell. I have .75 acre and it takes about gallon, but again, I didn't measure. It just feels like it uses more. With tractor I was getting gas maybe twice a season (5gal canister). Now I got gas 3 times already.How much fuel is your mower using? Mine uses about .75 gallons an acre. That seems to be about average for most ztr mowers.