Briggs recommends synthetic oil in certain conditions. 15w-50 synthetic in very warm temperatures. Synthetic 5w-30 in very cold to warm.
Currently, were I live the price difference between brand named dyno oils and some synthetics is about a dollar. The difference is not as large as it once was. I am not sure why? However, That is an other topic for a new thread.
I am trying to understand why this oil turned grey and what to do about it. Moisture perhaps?. How would the water get in the crank case? This is a 12 year old machine that has always been stored out doors under a tarp.
I am also trying to help him get some more use out of this engine. if in fact it is wearing out and the grey color is metal particles. Perhaps bearing journals or aluminum from the block. This engine is not sleeved.
He says it does burn some oil. That is hard for me to judge, as what does "some" means. I have read that the 15w-50 is good for oil burners. I do not know that for sure. This is why I am asking.
You can theorize that while it is in storage, more oil may leak in to the top of the cylinder and cause a lot of smoke at start up. While at temp it would not burn as much as it is at the 50 viscosity level. So it seem to be a bit of a trade off. It would lube critical engine parts better. Not smoke as badly or carbon up as badly. You know it is an oil burner so you do not need the visible and annoying reminder by having an exhaust cloud that people may complain about.
At this point, My thought process is to put the engine back together with new gaskets and solve the valve cover leak. Drain the old oil and replace with 10w-30(because it will drain better). Then run it for a short period. Observe and see if it gets grey again and how much it may smoke. Let it get hot and drain again to help flush the engine clean of any water, debris and old oil. Next I would fill with Briggs and Stratton 15w-50 or a 15w-40. I was toying with the idea of a straight 40 weight.
Finally, Why change the oil in the Fall and not in the Spring? Why does that make any difference? My curiosity has me on this one.
If it gets him through the season I think he would appreciate it quite a bit.