Now for the burning question,
Did you buy the replacement from a mower shop, a real retail outlet or a pretend on line shop ?
Ever wondered what happens to all the parts made in cheap labour countries that fail the QC testing for Briggs /Kohler / Honda etc ?
They ultimately end up on the site of an on line seller at an unreal low price, truthfully advertised as OEM part, they just neglect to tell you that they are quality control failures.
If it came from a mower shop take it back and ask them to test it. If the counter staff go red in the face then slink off like a sly dog & give you a replacement, naked then it is a knock off of dubious quality.
Good ones come in branded boxes ( or bags ) and will have both a part number and batch / serial number on them,.