Who calibrated your digital unit?I do check mine with a digital torque adapter. That how found out how lousy HFT torque wrenches were. One was nearly double the torque setting before it clicked. No wonder I was snapping bolts
Also you should unload the torque wrenches when you not using them as leaving them loaded can cause the calibration to become un-calibrated.
Tap Magic doesn't work very on aluminum. I have tried it then my machinist suggest the alcohol.I recall AlumaTap when I worked in machine shops. If you used Tap Free on Aluminum it would turn it black. Back in the day. Now they have tapping fluids that claim to work on all metals. Tap Majic.
That is what happens when they make a product that accommodates too many options. Too many compromises. It does not work well at anything while claiming it can do everything.Tap Magic doesn't work very on aluminum. I have tried it then my machinist suggest the alcohol.