I think the compression should usually be higher when warm. Everything expands and tighter clearances.
Just a thought...
I have some OMC Engine Tune. It came in both aerosol and gallon jugs. It will (supposedly) break down carbon deposits and clean the rings/ring grooves in the piston.
It is for the outboard engines. You would pulse spray it in the intake bore of a warm, running engine without stalling out, then at the end you let it flow until stall. Let it sit for an hour, then fire it up and let it burn off.
I would also go in the spark hole and spray the bore with the little aerosol tube, too.
You can get a similar product at West Marine by their 2 cyc oil display by QuickSilver.
Black and sooty is fuel related.
Oil, oil mixture, fuel, fuel additives, and/or carbureation too rich.
And, as I'm sure we know, the spark plug looking like the color of cocoa powder is ideal. (so dad taught me)
I grew up hearing about a "hotter spark plug" when your old worn engine has a greasy oily black spark plug.
10 years ago, I attended a Champion seminar at an aviation show. Turns out the hotter plug has to do with, no, not a hotter spark...
... but, the spark plugs ability to remove heat from the cylinder. Huh?!?
Turns out that they make a longer porcelain insulator snout that is less inclined to transfer the heat to the surrounding cylinder head, thus making the cylinder run a little hotter.