Apologies, yes, choke valve on the carburetor fully closed. I messed that one up (thread title adjusted).
After cleaning the solenoid it ran great for a few hours, actually got the lawn mowed! Then it started stuttering again at higher RPM and black smoke started coming out of the exhaust.
I removed the spark plugs and they were covered in black soot, one dry, one wet. Put new spark plugs in and the stuttering was gone for a few minutes, then returned.
Removed the spark plugs again, left side clear, right side covered in black soot again.
The air filter isn't in great shape but even without the filter it produces the black smoke. Fuel is fresh and oil is full (oil looks gold brown color and is pretty runny).
Not sure if I should start a new thread for this or to just keep going here, pls let me know which is better