Are you using OEM belts or after market as it does makes a difference as this mower is basically using the MTD CVT drive system and it is very pecky on what belts are used. Basically the secondary belt is a MTD 954-04208A (Toro PN 112-0305) which is MTD spec'd 5/8" x 41.5" belt. It has a different profile than regular 5/8 belts.