I had to replace the mandrel ( just the bering housing - the spindle part was original) on my '90 murray the other day - the bottom blade holder nut was a bear getting off ( have to to keep blade from spinning) - had to remove pulley- that nut was also a serious pain to remove .
When i put it all back together, I didnt spare any strength puttin em back on - i cranked the heck out of em, because i also had to draw the piece on the bottom in - it didnt break on me - that was a factory mandrel from 1990 that i replaced.
I bet your first mandrel was made in china - cheep crap.....