Export thread

SCAG Tiger Cat II vs KUBOTA ZD

#1

G

Gunhead58

Good afternoon all. I'm about a week away from making a final decision but after the last two weeks of research, my head is about to explode. I'm hoping to find anyone who can give me first hand experience with either the Kubota ZD1011 54" Zero Turn Mower (Diesel) or the SCAG Tiger Cat II 52" Gas burner. Both seem to have very good ratings (for the most part) and the Kubota dealer has been in business since 1946 (3rd generation). They actually sell both the Kubota and the SCAG. The Diesel Kubota is $3K more. The mower will be used for personal use only but I have a large portion of pasture that I want to cut and keep somewhat manicured once I build our "final home". I have a 55hp Mahindra that I use for the bulk of the pasture but my current residential JD riding mower is on its last leg. And with the Hog problem we have in Texas, the area I will be cutting will totally destroy (in my opinion) your average residential mower. Lots of ruts and gophers. So excluding the price, I would like this to be my last Riding Mower purchase. Any advice given would be greatly appreciated. Thx.


#2

jekjr

jekjr

Good afternoon all. I'm about a week away from making a final decision but after the last two weeks of research, my head is about to explode. I'm hoping to find anyone who can give me first hand experience with either the Kubota ZD1011 54" Zero Turn Mower (Diesel) or the SCAG Tiger Cat II 52" Gas burner. Both seem to have very good ratings (for the most part) and the Kubota dealer has been in business since 1946 (3rd generation). They actually sell both the Kubota and the SCAG. The Diesel Kubota is $3K more. The mower will be used for personal use only but I have a large portion of pasture that I want to cut and keep somewhat manicured once I build our "final home". I have a 55hp Mahindra that I use for the bulk of the pasture but my current residential JD riding mower is on its last leg. And with the Hog problem we have in Texas, the area I will be cutting will totally destroy (in my opinion) your average residential mower. Lots of ruts and gophers. So excluding the price, I would like this to be my last Riding Mower purchase. Any advice given would be greatly appreciated. Thx.

I can't tell you about the ZD1011 but I used to run a ZD326. I thought it was the cat's meow. Then I had to buy another mower because my business had grown to need another one. I was prepared to buy another 326. I demonstrated a Tiger Cat Scag with the 52" deck. I was blown away at the difference in the cut. I bought my first Tiger Cat in July of 2014. I traded the Kubota 326 Diesel for the second one in April of 2015. I bought my third one in April of 2016.

The Kubota is a good mower but it will not cut tall stemmed grass with the Scag Tiger Cat with the 52" deck. I ran the 326 in the same yards with the Tiger Cat. As far as I am concerned they are not on the same planet.

Blade changes are a breeze on the Scag. We change blades two and some times three times a day this time of year. With the Kubota it takes about twice as long and with the Scag you do not have to get underneath it like you do the Kubota. Use a cordless impact wrench and tighten them from the top side.

If you run them till they are out of warranty and for some freak reason lost an engine to a catastrophic failure the Kawasaki gas engine will be a fraction of the price that the Kubota will be to replace.

If you have to change a belt on the deck. The Kubota is a pretty good job to replace. On the Scag Tiger Cat it is just a few minutes and the only tools needed are a 1/2" Drive ratchet and an extension to hold the tensioner back to get it on.

If you for some reason mess up a blade bolt. On the Kubota you have got to remove the entire spindle because it threads in from the bottom. On the Scag the bolt goes all the way through and all you have to do is take a wafer blade on a 4" side grinder and cut it off and put a new one in and you are running again in minutes verses hours of down time.

My oldest Scag has over 1500 hours on it. My second one has around 1000 hours on it and my newest one has about 500 hours on it and they have all been abused terribly and they are like a Timex watch used to be. They take a licking and come back ticking.

I see people every day running the Kubota mowers and I still have a ZG222 Kubota that we use to pick uo leaves. The Kubota mowers are not junk BUT they will not cut stemmed grass with the Scag. We cut bahia grass in one pass with the Scags that the Kubota mowers will have to go over twice to get the same results.

Like I said I have three and we cut a lot of grass with them. Personally running commercially if they gave me a brand new Kubota and said it is yours you just have to run it, you can't sell it. I would give it back to them and buy a Scag if I needed a new mower.

If there was another mower sold locally that would out cut a Scag Tiger Cat I would be running them.

I traded a 326 Diesel with 800 hours in that resold used for more than I paid for the Tiger Cat new. I was glad to get rid of it.

I can say the 326 was a pretty trouble free mower as far as major problems. There are however a lot of things on it that could be very expensive after the warranty goes out verses the simpler design of the Tiger Cats.

I have a friend that has a Tiger Cub Scag that is over 20 years old and it still runs like a top also. He has never had any major problems with it. he cuts probably an acre to acre and a half with it.

Hope that helps.


#3

55TBird

55TBird

Good afternoon all. I'm about a week away from making a final decision but after the last two weeks of research, my head is about to explode. I'm hoping to find anyone who can give me first hand experience with either the Kubota ZD1011 54" Zero Turn Mower (Diesel) or the SCAG Tiger Cat II 52" Gas burner. Both seem to have very good ratings (for the most part) and the Kubota dealer has been in business since 1946 (3rd generation). They actually sell both the Kubota and the SCAG. The Diesel Kubota is $3K more. The mower will be used for personal use only but I have a large portion of pasture that I want to cut and keep somewhat manicured once I build our "final home". I have a 55hp Mahindra that I use for the bulk of the pasture but my current residential JD riding mower is on its last leg. And with the Hog problem we have in Texas, the area I will be cutting will totally destroy (in my opinion) your average residential mower. Lots of ruts and gophers. So excluding the price, I would like this to be my last Riding Mower purchase. Any advice given would be greatly appreciated. Thx.

I took my Turf Tiger II in for service and they gave me a Tiger Cat II with a 61" deck to use as a loaner. It is an awesome mower and I liked it a lot. It is very similar to my Turf Tiger with the primary difference being horse power. The Tiger Cat had a 23 hp Kawasaki engine as I recall and my Turf Tiger has the 35 hp Briggs Vanguard engine. The only time I noticed the power difference was getting near the top of a 21˚ hill.

I've never owned a Kubota but I will say that you would love the Tiger Cat.

However....if you can afford the extra 3 thousand bucks, you might consider the Turf Tiger II....especially if you are mowing really rough ground. The Turf Tiger has a double steel frame, a shaft drive and 16cc hydraulic gear pumps vs. 12cc. Plus more hp.

But both the Turf Tiger and Tiger Cat have the same deck and seat suspension. The quality of the cut was the same and the comfort was the same. Our friend jekjr would recommend the Tiger Cat over the Turf Tiger because you can do the same job for 3K less and it is hard to argue with that. And he is a pro so he has the hours to support that. But if you can afford a Turf Tiger II, I'd give it a look. I absolutely love mine.

Attachments





#4

55TBird

55TBird

Oh, one more thing. Where I live...I'd say at least 80% of the professional mowing service trailers I see are carrying Scags. That was the reason I chose a Scag.


#5

G

Gunhead58

Thank you very much. I'll keep everyone posted on what I decide. Thx again.


#6

jekjr

jekjr

Oh, one more thing. Where I live...I'd say at least 80% of the professional mowing service trailers I see are carrying Scags. That was the reason I chose a Scag.

I thought about you guys this morning. We cut some Bahia Grass that was three weeks since it was cut. It has rained an incredibly lot so three week old Bahia grass that has been rained on several times a week for three weeks is one tough mess to cut with anything. My two Tiger Cats cut it slick. I wish I had been able to take time and stop and take some pictures for y'all to see.

I guarantee you that we would have had to double cut every inch of it with Kubota mowers. Some of it possibly a third time to make it as smooth as the Scags cut it in one pass.


#7

G

Gunhead58

Thanks. I'm sure it looked great.


#8

Sweats

Sweats

Here's two more cents from a guy who only has experience with a Scag. I bought a Tiger Cat II with a 61" deck and a Kohler 29hp EFI in May and have put just over 40 hours on it since. I routinely mow about four acres. My terrain is a little hilly and VERY bumpy. I mean bumpy to the point where I mow 3-5 mph most of the time; otherwise, I'm mowing slower still. I also have all sorts of obstacles to contend with. The Scag replaces the services of a John Deere 300C with a 48" deck and a 24hp B&S motor, and a 32hp John Deere 3203 compact utility tractor pulling a 72" Bush Hog finish mower. With my prior combination, my wife and I would get out there and take about 3 1/2 hours to mow the four acres. It takes almost exactly the same amount of time with the Tiger Cat alone but it's much more comfortable. I attribute the comfort entirely to the suspension seat. As far as the overall experience, I haven't had anything even remotley negative occur with the Scag - not one thing. It runs great, has plenty of power, drives easily, and it cuts beautifully.

55Tbird loves his Turf Tiger and would have you try one. I'll tell you, if I had the money, I'd probablly have gone that direction for the frame and weight alone but when my wife set our initial budget at $5,000, well, you get the picture. Still, the Tiger Cat has felt so far like it's going to be just fine for the long haul.

Finally, a note on diesels vs gas, and the a thought on your dealer. I've read plenty of testimony on the merits of diesel motors. However, I worked with a guy a couple of years ago who was just starting a mowing business. The business grew quickly and he soon bought a pair of diesels to go with his two gas mowers (all John Deere in this story). About a year later, he traded in the diesels and went with gas only. He has eight mowers now and all are gas. I'm not sure why he didn't go the diesel route but am now more curious than ever. I know you're getting close to making your decision, so I'll try to get in touch with the guy soon, for what it's worth. As far as your dealer is concerned, you'd mentioned he was a Kubota dealer but you suggested (and I'm paraphrasing here) he might be leaning every so slightly in the Scag direction. I have to wonder, if he, being a Kubota dealer, liked the Kubota more, might he not lean a little (lot) more heavily in that direction? I wonder if his affiliation with Kubota influences his stance, openly at least. I'd like to know what he'd say after a couple of beers (and this in no way a judgement on the man's character). Just a thought. Anyway, happy hunting and good luck to you!


#9

G

Gunhead58

Great info. Thank you. I will consider all.


#10

jekjr

jekjr

Welllll Have you bought it yet and what did you buy?


#11

G

Gunhead58

I went into it thinking I was going with the Kubota. After talking to a lot of people (probably too many) and going to see them both, I'm now leaning toward the SCAG. I've just got to get comfortable with my decision and then pull the trigger. At my age and five years from retiring, I have to spend my kids and grandkids inheritance wisely. Thx for all the input. I'll post pix when I get it home.... Thx.


#12

jekjr

jekjr

I went into it thinking I was going with the Kubota. After talking to a lot of people (probably too many) and going to see them both, I'm now leaning toward the SCAG. I've just got to get comfortable with my decision and then pull the trigger. At my age and five years from retiring, I have to spend my kids and grandkids inheritance wisely. Thx for all the input. I'll post pix when I get it home.... Thx.


You will not be going wrong with the Kubota as far as a quality machine. However it will not cut grass with the Scag. I would say we have abused two Tiger Cats this week but that is not a strong enough word. More like Assaulted or molested two Tiger Cats this week. I honestly wish you could have been here to see it and run a Kubota along side and see the difference. That is where the Scag shines. Tall Bahia Grass is a beast to deal with and we have cut some that has not been cut in 2 and at times 3 weeks because of the weather.


#13

T

Todd727

Just traded my ZD331 for a Turf Tiger II, (61" Velocity with the B&S Big Block). First mowing with it was within minutes of bringing it home. After 3 hours, I couldn't be more pleased. The ZD would leave taller, stemmed grass uncut. Was very frustrating. I'd bought new blades, new belt, reduced speed, raised the deck, etc. Then I found out that others had the same issues.

The Scag did a perfect job and I ran faster. Ergonomics are great. The suspension seat made for a smooth ride, and I'm cutting former pasture that until last year was bush hogged with a full size farm tractor.

I did miss the hydraulic deck lift, but I'm going to have a stronger right leg for it. :laughing:

I also will miss the ease of fueling diesel from my farm tank and not having to schlep unleaded, but for the price premium of a diesel, I'll deal with it. As far as mechanical reliability, I believe they are both equals, although, I'm also happy to leave the liquid cooling behind. That is just another failure point in my mind.

All in all, the Kubota may have a more recognizable name to the general public, but Scag is a better machine for the job.


#14

jekjr

jekjr

Just traded my ZD331 for a Turf Tiger II, (61" Velocity with the B&S Big Block). First mowing with it was within minutes of bringing it home. After 3 hours, I couldn't be more pleased. The ZD would leave taller, stemmed grass uncut. Was very frustrating. I'd bought new blades, new belt, reduced speed, raised the deck, etc. Then I found out that others had the same issues.

The Scag did a perfect job and I ran faster. Ergonomics are great. The suspension seat made for a smooth ride, and I'm cutting former pasture that until last year was bush hogged with a full size farm tractor.

I did miss the hydraulic deck lift, but I'm going to have a stronger right leg for it. :laughing:

I also will miss the ease of fueling diesel from my farm tank and not having to schlep unleaded, but for the price premium of a diesel, I'll deal with it. As far as mechanical reliability, I believe they are both equals, although, I'm also happy to leave the liquid cooling behind. That is just another failure point in my mind.

All in all, the Kubota may have a more recognizable name to the general public, but Scag is a better machine for the job.

I was running a ZD 326 Kubota in my business. I was in the process of buying another one as well. I also had and still have a ZG 222 Kubota. I demonstrated a Scag and was literally blown away at the difference. I bought a Tigercat with the 52" Velocity Deck with the 22 Hp Kawasaki on it. The Tigercat with the 52" deck would literally cut circles around the ZD 326. I bought the 326 in April of 2013. I bought the Tiger Cat in July of 2014. I traded the 326 in on another Tigercat in April of 2015. The 326 had a little over 800 hours on it. In April 2016 I bought the Third Tigercat. My oldest now has over 1500 hours on it. The second one has around 1000 hours on it and the third one is clocking towards 600 hours. We operate them under brutal conditions cutting at times acres of Pensacola Bahia grass that is cut on two week cycles. With all of the rain we have had this summer here in Lower Alabama we have at times had to cut some of it that had not been cut in 3 weeks. The Tiger Cats will cut it in one pass without leaving the stubbles sticking up as long as you change blades on them every two to three acres in that kind of cutting. In other kinds of grass they will go longer.

As far as I am concerned the Scag with the Velocity Deck is not even on the same planet as the Kubota as far as being able to do the job. I basically was running a $14K machine and about to buy another one when I went to running $8500 machines that are far superior as far as being able to do the job.

We change blades on the Scags most days twice a day and at times 3 times a day. We run them under some of the most brutal conditions that I can imagine a mower running under and they are ready to go all day every day with little to no problems. We cut an average of 90 properties every two weeks varying from 15 acres down. Many times we can cut a 4 acre property with two Scag Tigercats in an hour from the time they hit the ground till they are going back up the ramp on the trailer. That is hooked up in bi-weekly cut grass. My Kubotas would require us to double cut much of the grass we cut because they would not cut smooth.

If somebody would show me a better mower that was sold locally to where we live I would be running them. I have not seen it yet.

We cut properties that at times people passing on the road will stop and look at where we are cutting and shake their heads and ask, "where did you find that mower. I have to have one of those. That is incredible."

As far as I am concerned there is nothing out there that will out cut the Tiger Cat Scag with the 52" deck literally. We have demonstrated the Turf Tigers with the 61" deck on several occasions and we think that the Tiger Cats with the 52" decks out cut them in tall stemmed grass. Obviously the Tiger Cat has fast ground speed and 9 more inches of width but The cut of the Tiger Cat with the 52" is smoother and it seems to cut grass a little faster than the Turf Tiger will. Although the Turf Tiger has a faster max ground speed.

We can change blades on the Tigercats and grease the spindle bearings in under 10 minutes on two mowers. It would take us 20 minutes or so to change blades on the ZD 326 and it takes longer on the ZG222. We now only use the ZG222 with a bagger system to get up leaves in the winter time.

If a Scag will live for us they will live for anybody. At the end of the day we have gutted anything we run.


Top