I agree regular white is too stark; I just need to see what the big box has in an off-white/light ivory. It’s not really that much area and a few turns through the yard makes it a stupid question, but I did want something close.Not for white. I would look for a slightly off white or dirty white. Not pure clean white.
What are you using for the Snapper red? Think Krylon Cherry Bomb Red was a close to Snapper red. I have several old to new series pushers. The red is different on every one. Hard to tell once you use them and they get dirty.