The blue stuff is sealer. A seal is delicate. You said you used a thin wall tube as a driver, which may have been difficult to perfectly match to the outer shell of the seal. A quick initial check is that the seal will only just fit into the chamfer of the housing and must be pressed or driven square to seat. If you have the means measure the od of the seal and id of the housing bore. Sould be different by ?.001" ? Check for egg shape. If you did not destroy the original check the od. Good luck.