I am not sure of the exact model number of your engine but the service manual for the CH26 shows a maximum voltage of 14.7. Sometimes a battery can create weird issue throwing the voltage off. If the voltage doesn't exceed 14.8 on your meter I wouldn't get too concerned since that would be within the accuracy limits of most meters. Where you will get into issues if the voltage gets up around 16 volts or more.
May want to try the test with a different battery if possible. The battery being 3 years old could be starting to get some internal issues causing it to not absorb the current correctly.