Well to each his own, you can buy either but the warranty could save you a bundle if something major goes wrong and I don't trust Ariens but that's just me. There's things about each that could make one better than the other, it just depends on what one thinks or that's important to you. I had my choice of Hustler, Scag or Toro and Toro had the best warranty and price. The GS has the 5 yr 1200 hr warranty.