So this place you took your mower to is in the business of stealing spark plugs and air filters? Sounds very lucrative.
Here's what I'm suggesting:
Take the mower back to the 'free' community site and tell them that you brought your mower in "X" days ago and had work done on it. It had been running fine before they worked on it; now it won't run.
They'll either say, "Let us take a look at it" or they'll tell you to "Get out of here!" and steal the whole lawnmower, in which case you won't be out much.
My guess is they'll say, "Let's take a look at it."