I didn't do the PTO replacement, it was done at a Toro shop by the previous owner. I talked with the service dept and they shared the service record as far as they replace the PTO. When I look at the part drawing the PTO and pulley are one assembly. (It's buried under the mower and I have not done a complete inspection of that area yet.) I did just finish tightening the deck drive belt as it appeared somewhat loose, but tach reading is the same.
And thanks for the quick response and thought. It did cross my mind that possibly the wrong PTO with a residential diameter was used. But parts lists don't show 2 different PTO's, one for 17,500 and the other for 18,500 FPM.