Do I actually need a blade balance?

Alright so a couple weeks in with the X350 and Im already down the rabbit hole of blade care lol. Cut looked a little uneven last mow and figured its time to pull em, sharpen, put em back.
Watched a bunch of vids and now Im more confused than when I started. Half the guys say just stick a screwdriver through the center hole, eyeball it, if one side dips down grind that side till it sits level. Other half swear you need an actual balancer or the vibration will kill your spindles over time.
Then I came across this blade balancer. Its magnetic, mounts on the wall, you set the blade on the cone and it tells you which side is heavy. Looks way more accurate than the screwdriver trick but part of me wonders if Im overthinkin it for a homeowner rig thats only cuttin 1.5 acres. Or should I just skip the whole sharpen and balance thing and drop a fresh set of blades on instead? Wanna hear what you guys actually do.
 
I grew up in a commercial golf course equipment company in the Midwest. At a young age I learned to sharpen rotary blades, This included balancing on a "Magna-Matic" Blade balancer. 60 years later I am still using a Magna-Matic. But apparently the patent has run out and the Chinese have decided to make them. This makes it easier to acquire one as the Magna-Matic was a $100.00. I was taught, "think about it, don't you balance a tire on your car? That always made sense to me and I found 1 in 3 new blades are so out of balance, it would shake your fillings out of you head. Before A.N.S.I., That law that came about because two idiots picked up a push rotary and tried to trim hedges with it and lost fingers, The blades were hard and went as fast as the manufacturer could spin them. Today, blade tip speed is regulated and the blades are so soft that they will not hold an edge for a whole day. In Illinois, blades would last a season even being sharpened regularly. I now live in Florida, on 5 acres and I am happy to get 3 mowings out of a set of homeowner blades( much thinner than commercial rotary blade) before they are completely worn out by the sand. So balancing is as much as a worry. BTW, I also balance the tires on my trailers. Have you ever followed a trailer bouncing and dancing down the interstate .
If you sharpened less your blades would last much longer.Your training/theories are myth ie not based in science. :devilish:
 
Alright so a couple weeks in with the X350 and Im already down the rabbit hole of blade care lol. Cut looked a little uneven last mow and figured its time to pull em, sharpen, put em back.
Watched a bunch of vids and now Im more confused than when I started. Half the guys say just stick a screwdriver through the center hole, eyeball it, if one side dips down grind that side till it sits level. Other half swear you need an actual balancer or the vibration will kill your spindles over time.
Then I came across this blade balancer. Its magnetic, mounts on the wall, you set the blade on the cone and it tells you which side is heavy. Looks way more accurate than the screwdriver trick but part of me wonders if Im overthinkin it for a homeowner rig thats only cuttin 1.5 acres. Or should I just skip the whole sharpen and balance thing and drop a fresh set of blades on instead? Wanna hear what you guys actually do.

Alright so a couple weeks in with the X350 and Im already down the rabbit hole of blade care lol. Cut looked a little uneven last mow and figured its time to pull em, sharpen, put em back.
Watched a bunch of vids and now Im more confused than when I started. Half the guys say just stick a screwdriver through the center hole, eyeball it, if one side dips down grind that side till it sits level. Other half swear you need an actual balancer or the vibration will kill your spindles over time.
Then I came across this blade balancer. Its magnetic, mounts on the wall, you set the blade on the cone and it tells you which side is heavy. Looks way more accurate than the screwdriver trick but part of me wonders if Im overthinkin it for a homeowner rig thats only cuttin 1.5 acres. Or should I just skip the whole sharpen and balance thing and drop a fresh set of blades on instead? Wanna hear what you guys actually do.

Alright so a couple weeks in with the X350 and Im already down the rabbit hole of blade care lol. Cut looked a little uneven last mow and figured its time to pull em, sharpen, put em back.
Watched a bunch of vids and now Im more confused than when I started. Half the guys say just stick a screwdriver through the center hole, eyeball it, if one side dips down grind that side till it sits level. Other half swear you need an actual balancer or the vibration will kill your spindles over time.
Then I came across this blade balancer. Its magnetic, mounts on the wall, you set the blade on the cone and it tells you which side is heavy. Looks way more accurate than the screwdriver trick but part of me wonders if Im overthinkin it for a homeowner rig thats only cuttin 1.5 acres. Or should I just skip the whole sharpen and balance thing and drop a fresh set of blades on instead? Wanna hear what you guys actually do.
 
Maintenance questions with respect to "any" equipment touch upon what Economists refer to as the Law of Diminishing returns. Since the more you put into maintenance, the less, ( or later), you you can expect to incur repair or replacement costs, maintenance is generally a good idea. That said, no amount of maintenance will defer repairs or replacement indefinitely. The question becomes how much $$ do you want to put into maintenance in the interest of deferring replacement or repair incrementally longer. The answer, unfortunately, is it depends.

Future repair and replacement costs are all but impossible to predict with any accuracy. Furthermore, they tend to present with a certain degree of urgency. When equipment or vehicles break down, work and transportation stops until the situation is resolved. For this reason I tend to lean heavily toward the maintenance side of equipment running costs as maintenance is something I can plan for including shopping for needed materials and tools often getting either or both on sale. Repairs, by contrast, have me at a repair shop with my wallet out begging the owner / manager to take me in "today". You don't need to be Donald Trump to know this is not the best of bargaining positions to be in. Savvy guys with home workshops full of tools they know how to use may scoff at this rationale but you can bet their Accountants or their kids' Teachers, who only know enough to check oi levels before starting the engine, won't.

I change oil at the end of every season regardless of the running hours on the machine and I sharpen and balance blades whenever I have time to do it even when the sharpening / balancing takes less time than removing and reinstalling the blades. I use a flapper disc on my $30 grinder and don't try to grind out nicks. I just sharpen and balance and my blades will probably outlast me, (I'm old). This also allows me to detect and remove debris like string around spindles or small pockets of grass residue accumulating under the deck before problems develop and while the job only takes minutes to do.

Maintenance overkill = virtually free. A day at the shop when you've bribed the Manager to take you next = not so much.
 
I grew up in a commercial golf course equipment company in the Midwest. At a young age I learned to sharpen rotary blades, This included balancing on a "Magna-Matic" Blade balancer. 60 years later I am still using a Magna-Matic. But apparently the patent has run out and the Chinese have decided to make them. This makes it easier to acquire one as the Magna-Matic was a $100.00. I was taught, "think about it, don't you balance a tire on your car? That always made sense to me and I found 1 in 3 new blades are so out of balance, it would shake your fillings out of you head. Before A.N.S.I., That law that came about because two idiots picked up a push rotary and tried to trim hedges with it and lost fingers, The blades were hard and went as fast as the manufacturer could spin them. Today, blade tip speed is regulated and the blades are so soft that they will not hold an edge for a whole day. In Illinois, blades would last a season even being sharpened regularly. I now live in Florida, on 5 acres and I am happy to get 3 mowings out of a set of homeowner blades( much thinner than commercial rotary blade) before they are completely worn out by the sand. So balancing is as much as a worry. BTW, I also balance the tires on my trailers. Have you ever followed a trailer bouncing and dancing down the interstate .
I got a set of 'sand blades' from PSEP dot BIZ for my AYP 42". They have lasted a pretty long time here in GA. I think I have had them in use for over 10 years. Memory says there has been one sharpening over that time. They are a lot thicker gauge than what is normally supplied from the factory. As I recall, they were priced just about the same as regualr blades.
My cutting area, (not a 'lawn') grows whatever comes up and can live with whatever rain is provided and whatever nutrients it can drag out of the dirt. IOW, no fertilizer or sprinklers, so it is full natural whatever that gets trimmed. The blades have been more than I expected, and I would buy them again without hesitation. tom
 
Alright so a couple weeks in with the X350 and Im already down the rabbit hole of blade care lol. Cut looked a little uneven last mow and figured its time to pull em, sharpen, put em back.
Watched a bunch of vids and now Im more confused than when I started. Half the guys say just stick a screwdriver through the center hole, eyeball it, if one side dips down grind that side till it sits level. Other half swear you need an actual balancer or the vibration will kill your spindles over time.
Then I came across this blade balancer. Its magnetic, mounts on the wall, you set the blade on the cone and it tells you which side is heavy. Looks way more accurate than the screwdriver trick but part of me wonders if Im overthinkin it for a homeowner rig thats only cuttin 1.5 acres. Or should I just skip the whole sharpen and balance thing and drop a fresh set of blades on instead? Wanna hear what you guys actually do.
A lot people think they know better and some people want to sell you something.
A screwdriver is a blade balancer and it's all I have ever used.
Other people say don't balance them at all and it's a waste of time.
It's your call.
 
This is good enough. A large nail in a stud or tree works well. Balance is not as critical on a mower with multiple blades. However, balance is more important on single blade walk behind mowers.
In the past, I used a Philips screwdriver with a round shaft to balance the blades. It sorta worked. I finally bought the balancer your image shows. It works. It even indicates if the balance is correct front-to-back. Most times a little bit of trimming will bring it into balance that doesn't cause the mower deck to vibrate. This little tool is worth the price if you don't want to invest in something more expensive. Honestly, it works pretty well for something as low budget as it is. Lots better than a screwdriver or ratchet wrench extension.
 
I'm running the same spindles on my Cub Cadet Zero turn that I bought new in 2011. I keep a spare set of blades sharpened and swap out about 3 times a year. Sharpen my blades with 80 grit flapper disc and I use my eyeballs as a balancer. Have never had a problem. Keep spindles greased and mower maintained.
 
I've used a cheap plastic conical shaped balancer for years. It has done a great job of providing a true balance. I never have any vibration and the lawn has a great evenly cut look to it.
 
Alright so a couple weeks in with the X350 and Im already down the rabbit hole of blade care lol. Cut looked a little uneven last mow and figured its time to pull em, sharpen, put em back.
Watched a bunch of vids and now Im more confused than when I started. Half the guys say just stick a screwdriver through the center hole, eyeball it, if one side dips down grind that side till it sits level. Other half swear you need an actual balancer or the vibration will kill your spindles over time.
Then I came across this blade balancer. Its magnetic, mounts on the wall, you set the blade on the cone and it tells you which side is heavy. Looks way more accurate than the screwdriver trick but part of me wonders if Im overthinkin it for a homeowner rig thats only cuttin 1.5 acres. Or should I just skip the whole sharpen and balance thing and drop a fresh set of blades on instead? Wanna hear what you guys actually do.
 
Back
Top